The Eﬀects of Working Hours on Health
Status and Health Behaviors
Mar´ In´s Berniell∗
CEMFI - UIMP
This kind of study actions the eﬀect of the amount of operating hours upon workers' wellness status and health manners. To deal with the endogeneity with the number of hours worked I personally use a quasi-experiment: the change in the legal maximum workweek hours in France passed in 1998. The estimated eﬀects, while average, are all consistent with the idea that significantly less working hours improves well being behaviors. In particular, this paper shows that a discount of functioning time is definitely associated with a drop in the probability of smoking, in alcoholic beverages consumption, and in physical lack of exercise. I do not ﬁnd an immediate eﬀect of working time on health status procedures (self-assessed wellness status and an index of vital risk), probably mainly because I simply capture shortrun eﬀects. Nevertheless , since overall health behaviors directly aﬀect future health outcomes, we ought to expect a lengthy run eﬀect of the volume of hours worked on individual's wellness, through these changes upon health behaviors.
JEL Classiﬁcation: C21, I12, J08, J22, J28, J81.
My spouse and i am especially grateful to Guillermo Caruana and Manuel Bag¨´s for his or her encouragement and advise. I would ue
love to say thanks to Manuel Arellano, Claudio Michelacci, Laura Ondulado, Lian Allub, Lucila Berniell, Dolores de la Mata, Paul Dourgnon, Romain Fantin and attendants in CEMFI Expert Thesis Workshop Sessions pertaining to helpful comments and talks. Finally, I thank IRDES for providing me while using ESPS info. Any computations, analyses and interpretation based on the delivered data happen to be my only responsibility.
‘'... common emulation and desire of greater gain
frequently motivated them [workers]
to over-work themselves, and
to harm their overall health by extreme labour‘'.
A great Inquiry in to the Nature to result in of the Wealth of Nations. Adam Smith, 1776.
There is proof that work aﬀects health. An easy look at the data from the last European Working Conditions Survey (EWCS) shows that about 30% of workers in the European Union feel that their wellness is at risk because of their operate, and that the larger the number of several hours worked the higher is the discuss of employees who agree with it (Figure 2). Many studies try to estimation the impact of work on wellness, however the predicted sign with this eﬀect is usually ambiguous. On the one hand, some studies support the idea that work is wonderful for health, exhibiting for instance that nonworking folks are often discovered to have poorer health than the working inhabitants (Langeland, 2009). On the other hand, several studies emphasize the unfavorable eﬀect of on person's health (Sparks, Cooper, Fried, and Shirom, 1997), and recent literature -starting with Ruhm (2000)- shows that aggregate well being indicators increase when lack of employment increases.
The existence of this ambiguity in the predicted eﬀect could be related to the truth that there are a lot of weaknesses in previous research that can prejudice the outcomes. First, exploration in the wellness economics materials has not been in a position to ﬁnd a causal eﬀect of work upon health, since in most cases there is an endogeneity problem as a result of reverse causality -working hours aﬀects health but as well health aﬀects working hours- or third omitted elements that might inﬂuence health and operating hours as well. 1 For instance, in individuals studies helping the idea that individuals working more hours are more healthy than those doing work less, the results could possibly be driven by healthier people being able to function longer several hours and those with ill wellness having to function less hours, rather than even more working time leading to better health (see Section 2 . 1 to get more detail). Second, in the previous literary works the eﬀect of more hours worked has not been isolated in the income eﬀect usually connected to the enhancements made on time dedicated to work. a couple of Third, in a few studies the eﬀect of on overall health along the rigorous margin (work 1
References: Allonier, C., G. Dourgnon, and T. Rochereau (2006): " Sant´, attentions et protece
tion sociale en 2004, ” IRDES report, 1, 2379–90.
Arellano, M. (2005): " Empirical Evaluation of Public Plans: The Pursuit of
Causality., ” mimeo.
Askenazy, P. (2008): " A Primer for the 35-Hour in France, 1997-2007, ” IZA DP
Blundell, R., and M. Costa Dias (2007): " Alternative Methods to Evaluation
in Empirical Microeconomics, ”.
Boisard, P. (2004): Working period policy in France. Center d'´tudes para l'emploi.
Chemin, M., and E. Wasmer (2009a): " Regional Diﬀerence-in-Diﬀerences in France
Using the German born Annexation of Alsace-Moselle in 1870–1918, ”.
Estevao, Meters., and N. Sa (2008): " The 35-hour workweek in England: Straightjacket
or welfare improvement?, ” Monetary Policy, 23(55), 417–463.
35-hour workweek?, ” IZA DP No . 2459.
Gerdtham, U., and C. Ruhm (2006): " Fatalities rise in good economic occasions: evidence
in the OECD, ” Economics & Human Biology, 4(3), 298–316.
Goux, Deb., E. Maurin, and N. Petrongolo (2010): " Worktime Regulations and
Spousal Time Supply, ”.
Hamermesh, D. (2002): " Timing, togetherness and period windfalls, ” Journal of Population Economics, 15(4), 601–623.
Helsinki, Farreneheit. (2008): " Associations between working circumstances and behavioral risk
elements: The Helsinki Health Examine with Intercontinental Comparisons, ”.
Hill, C., and Farreneheit. Stafford (1980): " Parent care of children: Time diary estimates
of quantity, predictability, and range, ” Record of Human Resources, 15(2), 219–
Jackson, L., and P. Warr (2009): " Lack of employment and internal ill-health:
The moderating position of length and age, ” Psychological Medicine, 14(03), 605–614.
Johansson, E. (2004): " A note on the effects of several hours worked on fatality in OECD
countries, ” The Western Journal of Health Economics, 5(4), 335–340.
Jusot, N., M. Khlat, T. Rochereau, and C. Serme (2008): " Task loss by poor
health, smoking and obesity: a national possible survey in France, ” Journal of
Langeland, W. (2009): " Reported wellness diﬀerences between working and nonworking persons., ” Countrywide Institute of Occupational Well being, Department of Occupational Overall health Surveillance.
Mandin, C., and B. Palier (2002): " Welfare reform in Portugal, 1985-2002, ” Welfare
Maruyama, H., K. Kohno, and K. Morimoto (1995): " A report of precautionary
medicine pertaining to mental health among middle-management employees (Part
Mathers, C., and G. Schofield (1998): " The consequences of unemployment: evidence, ” Medical journal of Australia, 168, 178–185.
Maurin, E., and D. Thesmar (2004): " Changes in the Useful Structure of
Firms and the Demand for Skill, ” Diary of Labor Economics, 22(3).
McPherson, A., and T. Hall (1983): " Psychiatric impairment, physical health
and work ideals among unemployed and apprenticed young men, ” Australasian
Morrell, S., R. Taylor, and C. Kerr (1998): " Unemployment and young someones health, ” Medical Record of Australia, 168(5), 236–240.
Raposo, L., and L. Van Mine (2008): " How working time lowering aﬀects career and profits, ” IZA Discussion Papers.
Ruhm, C. (2000): " Are Recessions Good for Your Health?, ” Quarterly Journal of
Economics, 115(2), 617–650.
(2003): " Happy times make you sick, ” Record of Well being Economics, 22(4),
(2005): " Healthy living in crisis, ” Log of Well being Economics, 24(2),
Saffer, H., and K. Lamiraud (2008): The Eﬀect of Hours of Work on Sociable